Tile roofs have been a trusted choice for centuries, especially clay tiles. You can find them in many of Oklahoma’s historic properties as well as some modern homes since they’ve been protecting homes for decades with their durability, stark aesthetic appeal, and superb weather resistance.
But the roofing industry is rapidly improving, and there are more and more choices for your replacement. For example, back in the day, you only had the option of clay tiles, but now similar-looking tiles are manufactured with different materials.
Today, you have another option: stone-coated metal roof tiles. This modern alternative offers the look of traditional tile with added benefits like enhanced durability and lighter weight.
So, which one is right for your home? If you’re considering a new roof, understanding the differences between clay and stone-coated metal roof tiles is essential. Let’s break it down.
Clay Tiles vs. Stone-Coated Metal Tiles: A Quick Overview
Before we dive into the specifics, let’s introduce both options:
What Are Clay Tiles?
Clay tiles are made from natural clay that is shaped and baked at high temperatures. They are known for their classic, Mediterranean-style appearance, long lifespan, and ability to withstand high temperatures. These tiles have been used for centuries and continue to be a popular roofing choice today.
What Are Stone-Coated Metal Tiles?
Stone-coated metal tiles are made from metal (typically steel) that is coated with a layer of stone chips to enhance durability and appearance. They mimic the look of traditional tiles while offering modern benefits like being lightweight, impact-resistant, and highly weatherproof.
Also Read: What Is The Best Stone-Coated Steel Roofing?
Comparing Stone-Coated Metal Tiles vs. Clay Tile
Now that we understand what both these materials have to offer, it’s time to get to the heart of our article. In the following sections, we compare both of these roofing materials against factors that will play a crucial role in deciding which roof is best for you.
Which Roof Lasts Longer?
How Long Does A Clay Tile Roof Last?
Clay tiles are known for their longevity, often lasting 50 to 80 years. Some tiles can even last 100 years when properly maintained and installed correctly. This great longevity comes from the fact that clay is quite durable, even more so when it is baked.
However, these tiles are prone to cracking under impact, whether from falling branches, hail, or even heavy foot traffic during maintenance.
How Long Does a Stone-Coated Steel Roof Last?
Stone-coated metal roof tiles also offer impressive durability, with a lifespan of 40 to 70 years. They are highly impact-resistant, making them a great choice if you live in Oklahoma or any other area with frequent storms or hail. Unlike clay, they won’t crack under pressure. They’re also fire-resistant and can withstand extreme weather conditions, including strong winds.
Winner: If durability under impact is a concern, stone-coated metal roof tiles have the edge.
Which Roof Is Heavier? (Weight and Structural Considerations)
Clay Tile
One of the biggest downsides of clay tiles is their weight. They are extremely heavy, often requiring additional structural reinforcement. A clay tile roof can weigh around 600 to 1,500 pounds per square (100 square feet). This is among the highest when compared to other roofing materials. This can add significant stress to your home’s structure, and it’s not the right material to install if your home is not ready for it.
Stone-Coated Metal
In contrast, stone-coated metal tiles are lightweight, typically weighing 50 to 150 pounds per square. This makes installation easier and often eliminates the need for extra reinforcement, reducing costs and construction time. What we like is that despite the lighter weight, they do not compromise durability and wind resistance.
Winner: Stone-coated metal tiles are the best option in terms of weight, especially if your home’s structure isn’t built for heavy loads.
Aesthetic Appeal, Design, And Customization
Clay Tiles
Aesthetics are where clay tile roofs shine. They tend to offer a classic, European appeal, and they are available in various shapes (Spanish, mission, flat) and colors, with natural variations that enhance their charm. If you want an authentic Mediterranean or Spanish-style look, clay is the traditional choice..
Stone-Coated Metal Tiles
Stone-coated steel roofs mimic the look of clay tiles remarkably well. They come in various styles and colors, offering the appearance of traditional tile but with modern performance benefits. Unless you inspect the tiles closely, it’s often hard to tell the difference between clay and stone-coated metal from the street.
Winner: Tie—clay has an undeniably charming look, but stone-coated metal tiles offer a near-identical look with more flexibility.
Durability and Weather Resistance Tests
Clay Tiles
Clay tiles handle heat exceptionally well, making them a top choice for hot climates. However, they can struggle in freeze-thaw cycles, leading to cracks over time. The materials’ wind resistance is also good, but severe storms, especially tornadoes and hail storms, can cause breakage.
Stone-Coated Metal Tiles
Since the primary material in this option is steel (in some cases, aluminum), stone-coated metal roof tiles excel in extreme weather. They can withstand hurricane-force winds, heavy rain, and hail. Unlike clay, they don’t absorb water or crack from freezing temperatures.
Winner: Stone-coated metal roof tiles, especially for areas with extreme weather conditions.
Which Roof Will Cost More?
How Much Does A Clay Tile Roof Cost?
Clay tile roofs are a premium roofing option. Material costs alone range from $10 to $24 per square foot, with installation costs adding up significantly due to the labor-intensive process.
To know more about how much other types of tile roofs cost, visit our guide on: How Much Does a Tile Roof Cost In Oklahoma?
How Much Does a Stone Coated Steel Roof Cost?
Stone-coated roofs are also expensive, but when you compare them with clay tiles, they are slightly more affordable. Stone-coated metal roofs cost around $10 to $16 per square foot, with lower installation costs due to their lightweight nature.
Winner: Stone-coated metal roof tiles. While not technically ‘budget-friendly,’ they still come at a lower cost without sacrificing quality.
For more information on the factors that affect the final cost, read: How Much Does Stone-Coated Steel Roofing Cost?
Which Roof Is More Environmentally Sound?
Can You Recycle Clay Tiles?
Clay tiles are made from natural materials and are 100% recyclable. However, their production involves high energy consumption due to the kiln-firing process.
Can You Recycle Stone-Coated Metal Tiles?
Stone-coated metal tiles are also eco-friendly, often made from recycled materials, and fully recyclable at the end of their lifespan. Their lightweight nature also means fewer resources are needed for transportation and installation.
Winner: Tie.
Which Roof Is More Energy Efficient?
Clay Tiles
Clay’s natural thermal properties help regulate indoor temperatures by reflecting heat and allowing airflow beneath the tiles. This can reduce cooling costs in hot climates.
Stone-Coated Metal Tiles
Stone-coated metal tiles also offer excellent energy efficiency. Many come with reflective coatings that reduce heat absorption, keeping your home cooler. Additionally, metal roofing is often installed with an air gap beneath, improving insulation.
Winner: Clay has a slight edge when it comes to extremely hot climates.
| Basis (Out of 10) | Stone-Coated Steel | Clay Tile Roofs |
| Lifespan | 9 | 9.5 |
| Aesthetics | 9 | 10 |
| Durability | 9 | 8.5 |
| Cost | 10 | 9 |
| Energy Efficiency | 9 | 10 |
Final Verdict: Which One Should You Choose?
Both clay and stone-coated metal tiles offer unique benefits, but your choice depends on your priorities:
Choose clay tiles if you want a classic, historic look, and your home’s structure can handle the weight. They’re best for hot, dry climates.
Choose stone-coated metal tiles if you need a durable, lightweight, and cost-effective option that withstands extreme weather and requires less maintenance.
If you’re still unsure which option suits your home best, our team at A. Fricker Roofing and Waterproofing is here to help. We specialize in both clay and stone-coated metal tile roofs and can guide you in making the best choice for your home. Contact us today at (918) 402-7167 for a consultation!
